Why Mortgages Get Denied (And How to Make Sure Yours Isn’t)

On Tuesday, I got a call that every realtor dreads. A young couple I'd been guiding for three months, searching for their perfect home, had their mortgage denied, just three days before closing. They had a pre-approval, a solid down payment, and thought they were in the clear. I'd warned them to hold off on big purchases until after closing, but they opened a new credit card to grab some appliance deals for their new place. That one move changed their financial profile enough to sink the deal.

As a licensed realtor in Tennessee and Texas with seven years of experience, I've seen this scenario play out more times than I'd like. Mortgage denials aren't random; they follow patterns, and my job isn't to gloss over the challenges but to help you understand what lenders are looking for so you can avoid a similar heartbreak.

Here's a clear breakdown of why mortgage denials happen and a practical plan to keep your homebuying dreams on track.

The Credit Score Trap

Most people think credit scores are straightforward, but lenders dig much deeper than the number you see on your phone app. They're looking at your entire credit profile; even small changes can trigger red flags. In the case of the couple I mentioned earlier, the credit card dropped their average account age. It also increased their total available credit, which made underwriters nervous about their spending potential.

Credit scores below 620 make conventional loans nearly impossible. Even with scores in the 620-680 range, lenders scrutinize everything else twice as hard. I've watched clients with 720 credit scores get denied because they had too many recent inquiries or their credit utilization suddenly jumped from 15% to 45% right before closing.

The fix starts months before you even think about house hunting. Pay down existing balances and leave them paid down. Don't close old credit cards, thinking it will help; it actually hurts by reducing your available credit and shortening your credit history. Most importantly, once you start the mortgage process, pretend credit cards don't exist until after you get your keys.

Income Isn't Just About the Paycheck

First, lenders want to see consistent, predictable income that they can count on for the next 30 years. This requirement trips more people than expected, especially in today's economy. I've had clients who made significant money from contract jobs, freelancing, or side hustles, but couldn't prove steady income for the required two-year period.

Next, the debt-to-income calculation is where dreams often die, typically because lenders want your total monthly debt payments, including the new mortgage, to stay under 43% of your gross monthly income. Sometimes it's not about making more money; it's about owing less; hence, you could pay off a car loan or consolidate credit card debt and suddenly qualify for $50,000 more in home purchase power.

Finally, self-employed buyers face extra hurdles because tax write-offs that save money on taxes can hurt mortgage applications. When you write off business expenses, you're reducing the income on your tax returns; the same income lenders use to qualify you. Many successful business owners look broke on paper regarding the mortgage application process.

Employment History Matters More Than You Think

Job stability trumps higher pay in the mortgage world. I've seen clients get denied after landing better-paying jobs because they hadn't been there long enough. Lenders typically want to see two years in the same position or field, and switching jobs during the mortgage process is basically asking for trouble.

Even promotions can cause problems if they change your pay structure. This happened to one of my clients who got promoted from a salary to a salary-plus-commission structure right before applying. The lender couldn't count the commission income without two years of history, so their qualifying income went down despite the promotion.

If you're thinking about changing jobs, wait until after closing. If you must change jobs during the process, avoid contract jobs, ensure the job is in the same field with similar or better pay, and expect extra paperwork and delays.

Down Payment Documentation Nightmares

Money needs a paper trail, and lenders want to see where every dollar came from, especially large deposits. These deposits will kill deals faster than almost anything else. I've watched closings delayed for weeks while clients tried to document a cash deposit from selling furniture or getting paid back for a loan they made to a friend months earlier.

Similarly, gift money from family members requires specific documentation and seasoning requirements. The money typically needs to sit in your account for at least 60 days, or you need detailed gift letters and bank statements showing the source of funds. Even then, lenders limit how much of your down payment can come from gifts depending on the loan type.

The worst mistake is moving money around between accounts during the mortgage process. Every transfer creates questions that require documentation, so keep your money in one primary account and avoid any unusual financial activity from pre-approval through closing.

Property Problems That Sink Deals

Sometimes the house itself becomes the problem. Appraisals that come in low force you to either pay the difference in cash, renegotiate the price, or walk away. I've seen deals die because the appraiser found foundation issues, electrical problems, or other safety concerns that made the property ineligible for financing.

Likewise, condominiums create unique challenges because lenders have to approve the entire building, not just your unit. If the condo association doesn't meet specific financial requirements or if too many units are rented out instead of owner-occupied, you can't get conventional financing, no matter how qualified you are personally.

Flood zones, busy roads, and unusual property types are other property problems that can create financing hurdles and sink a home-buying deal. Sometimes, the perfect house just isn't financeable, and knowing this upfront can save months of wasted effort.

The Timeline That Kills Dreams

Most mortgage denials happen during underwriting, typically after you're under contract. The reason is that the pre-approval letters lenders give aren't guaranteed; they are educated guesses based on the information you provided. The real scrutiny happens when underwriters verify every detail of your financial life.

This is why I always tell clients to get fully underwritten pre-approval when possible. It takes longer upfront but eliminates most surprises later. In fact, some lenders will even lock your interest rate for extended periods if you're fully approved.

The mortgage process typically takes 30-45 days from application to closing, but delays are common. So, plan for 60 days and you'll rarely be disappointed or stuck with rushed timelines that easily create pressure, leading to mistakes and missed details.

Your Success Strategy

Start preparing six months before you plan to buy the house. Check your credit reports, gather financial documents, and start paying down debt strategically. Don't just focus on credit scores, look at the whole picture lenders will see.

Work with experienced professionals who communicate well and understand current lending requirements. The mortgage landscape changes constantly, and what worked last year might not work today.

Most importantly, don't make any major financial changes once you start the process. No new credit cards, no job changes, no large purchases, and no moving money around. The mortgage process rewards boring, predictable financial behavior.

Getting denied for a mortgage feels like a personal failure, but it's usually just a timing or preparation issue. I've helped countless clients bounce back from denials to become successful homeowners within 6-12 months. The key is understanding what went wrong and fixing it before trying again.

Your homeownership dreams aren't over; they just need better preparation. Ready to start your home-buying journey the right way? Book a quick call to discuss your goals. Let's make sure your next application gets approved.

Sign up for my newsletter below or book a quick call to talk about your goals. Let’s make your housing plans a reality!